Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Peter McLaughlin's avatar

I find the mustard-on-burgers thing fascinating. Outside of the US obviously ketchup is the default condiment of American food, whether on burgers or hotdogs or whatever. Mustard, if it's an option at all in the UK, is something you'd have to specifically ask for.

But it seems that (a) historically, mustard was the American condiment of choice for these foods, with ketchup a relatively latecomer, and (b) still to this day mustard much more common on burgers etc. within the US than outside the country. I see evidence of this in both burgers that you have mentioned thus far: the Damburger has mustard by default and ketchup as an extra, and the In-N-Out burger has mustard fried into the burger itself. Would be interested to hear if this is your perspective as well.

What's weird about this, to me, is that presumably ketchup was historically more alien to other countries than mustard? Mustard has been eaten for millennia, whereas ketchup in its current form is basically a nineteenth-century industrial product. It seems really odd that when American food made its way to e.g. Western Europe, such an emphasis was placed on the relatively-unfamiliar ketchup and the very-familiar mustard was dropped. Normally cross-cultural pollination of food involves changes being made to make foreign cuisines *more* familiar. But this change would seem to be the opposite. I'm sure there's some explanation, I just don't know what it is.

Do you have any sense of this as someone with experience of living (and, presumably, eating burgers and hot dogs etc.) both in and outside the US? For what it's worth, I would never have had mustard on my burgers until basically this year, but now I do it all the time.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts